| Platinum | Italiano's Pizza |
| Gold | Scorpio's Italian Eatery |
| Silver | Roma Pizza |
| Bronze | Roma Pizza Deltona |
| Top Pick | Blue Springs Brewing - Riverwalk Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Five Star Pizza |
| Top Pick | I Love New York Pizza |
| Top Pick | Monster Pizza |
| Top Pick | Roma Pizza Lake Helen |
| Top Pick | Stavro's Pizza and Grill |